The Psychological Trap in Negotiation: Understanding the Anchoring Effect

Imagine this: You walk into a market looking for a handbag. You find one you love, but the price tag shocks you—Rs. 15,000. It feels expensive, maybe even unreasonable. You start bargaining, and after some back-and-forth, the shopkeeper offers a 50% discount, bringing the price down to Rs. 7,500. Suddenly, the deal feels irresistible, and you decide to buy it.

Now, think about this—would you have been as eager to buy if the shopkeeper had originally priced it at Rs. 7,500 with no discount? Probably not. This is the power of anchoring in action. The initial high price of Rs. 15,000 set an anchor in your mind, making Rs. 7,500 seem like a bargain, even if that was the intended price all along.

There is a famous psychological experiment conducted by Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman where participants were asked to guess percentage of African countries that were in the UN. But here's the twist. Before they made their guess, a roulette wheel would spin, but it was rigged so it would always land on either the number 10 or the number 65. What they found is that that number on the roulette wheel, even though it was totally random, it changed people 's guess. Like the people who saw the number 10 guessed way lower on average for the percentage of African nations than those who saw 65.

Anchoring: The Hidden Force in Negotiation

Anchoring is the idea that the first number or piece of information presented in a negotiation sets a reference point—a psychological benchmark—that influences everything that follows. It is a cognitive bias that significantly influences human decision-making processes. Essentially, it refers to the tendency of individuals to place undue weight on the first piece of information they encounter when evaluating options or making choices. This initial information serves as an "anchor," thereby shaping perceptions and influencing subsequent judgments, often in unconscious ways.

When applied to the negotiation, the first offer made by either party often sets the tone for the rest of the discussion. For instance, if one party proposes a price that is considerably higher or lower than expected, it can skew the perceptions of value for both sides. The initial proposal, as an anchor, creates a reference point that affects how subsequent offers are viewed and negotiated. As negotiations progress, parties might find it challenging to move far from this anchor, even if both sides recognize its arbitrary nature. Thus, understanding the anchoring effect is vital for negotiators aiming to navigate their discussions more effectively and achieve favorable outcomes.

Setting an Anchor in a Negotiation

Setting an anchor effectively in a negotiation can put you in control of the conversation and shape the final outcome in your favor. Here’s how to do it:

1. Be the First to Throw Out a Number

The first number mentioned in a negotiation usually sets the reference point. If you’re selling, start high. If you’re buying, start low. Even if the other party counters, the final agreement is likely to revolve around your initial number.

📌 Example: If you’re negotiating a salary and aim for ₹1,00,000 per month, don’t wait for the employer to offer ₹80,000. Instead, start at ₹1,20,000, giving yourself room to negotiate while keeping the final number closer to your goal.

2. Justify Your Anchor with Logic and Data

A random number won’t hold weight. Back your anchor with facts, market data, or expert opinions to make it seem reasonable and credible.

📌 Example: When selling a used car, don’t just say, “I want ₹8,00,000.” Instead, say, “Similar models with this mileage and condition are selling for ₹8,50,000–₹9,00,000, so I’m pricing it at ₹8,00,000 for a quick sale.”

3. Frame the Anchor to Your Advantage

The way you present your anchor can influence how the other side perceives it. You can use:

• High-Precision Numbers: Instead of ₹10,00,000, say ₹10,27,500. This makes it seem well-calculated rather than arbitrary.

• Comparisons: Show that your offer is aligned with industry standards or better than alternatives.

• Scarcity or Exclusivity: Suggest that your offer is unique or time-sensitive to make it more appealing.

4. Use Extreme Anchors to Shift the Range

Even if you don’t expect to get your initial offer, setting an extreme anchor can pull the final agreement closer to your target. This works especially well in price negotiations.

📌 Example: If you’re selling a service worth ₹50,000, you might start at ₹70,000. The buyer may negotiate down, but you’re more likely to land around ₹55,000 rather than ₹40,000.

5. Control the Narrative Before Anchoring

Before throwing out a number, set the stage by discussing your value, expertise, or market conditions. This makes your anchor feel more justified.

📌 Example: Before discussing fees with a client, highlight your past success, testimonials, and industry benchmarks. Then state your rate confidently.

6. Prepare Your Anchor Before the Negotiation 🔍

One of the biggest mistakes negotiators make is walking in without a clear anchoring strategy. If you don’t plan your anchor, you risk being influenced by the other party’s anchor instead.

📌 Why it matters:

• A well-prepared anchor gives you confidence and control.

• It prevents you from being caught off guard by extreme offers.

• It allows you to frame the discussion in your favor right from the start.

How to prepare:

• Research market trends, competitor pricing, and industry benchmarks.

• Decide on your ideal, realistic, and bottom-line numbers.

• Anticipate counteroffers and prepare responses to justify your anchor.

📌 Example: If you’re negotiating a contract for consulting services, don’t just decide your rate on the spot. Research industry standards, factor in your expertise, and be ready to explain why your fee is justified.

Countering an Anchor thrown in Negotiation

What if the other party throws an anchor in the negotiation? If you are a buyer, it is a common practice that you will take an offer or quote from the supplier. That quote is nothing but an anchor thrown by the supplier. Normally, buyer will try to resist the anchor by proving that the offer price is too high. Again, it has been proven by studies that the more you resist an anchor, the stronger it becomes. Here are some of the techniques you may adopt to counter the anchor.

1. Diffuse the Anchor:

• Acknowledge the Offer: First, don’t reject the anchor outright. Acknowledge it politely, but show that you're not bound by it. This helps prevent immediate conflict.

  📌 Example:: "I see that you’re suggesting X, but I’d like to discuss the full context and some factors that might affect the final number."

• Express Openness: Show you're open to discussion and don’t automatically lock yourself into their frame. You can do this by reframing the anchor.

  📌 Example:: "I appreciate that, but based on my research/experience, a more realistic starting point would be Y."

2. Set Your Own Anchor:

• Establish Your Anchor Early: Before the negotiation deepens, subtly set your own anchor by introducing an ideal number that’s advantageous to you. This creates the foundation for the negotiation.

📌 Example:: "Given everything we’ve discussed, I believe a fair starting point would be Y."

3. focus on Your Own Value and Data:

• Present Objective Data: Bring in facts, figures, or precedents that back up your position. This shifts the conversation from emotions or arbitrary numbers to tangible elements.

  📌 Example:: "Let’s look at similar situations in the industry where the numbers typically range from X to Y."

• Explain the Logic Behind Your Position: Clarify why your counter-offer makes sense, supporting it with logical reasons or evidence.

  📌 Example:: "Given the quality of our services and the long-term value, my number reflects the scope of the work and the market value."

4. Ask Questions:

• Challenge the Anchor with Strategic Questions: This forces the other side to explain or justify their objection to your counter-offer. When they provide reasoning, it can often reveal their bottom-line.

  📌 Example:: "Why do you think our offer Y is high (or low)?"

5. Use Time to Your Advantage:

• Pause and Reflect: After addressing the anchor, create a moment of silence. This often puts psychological pressure on the other side to either defend their offer further or concede.

• Avoid Instant Responses: Resist the temptation to jump into a counter-offer. Taking your time makes you seem more confident and grounded.

6. Reframe the Negotiation:

• Shift the Focus: If the anchor still holds power, shift the conversation to non-price elements, such as quality, timelines, or other factors, to reposition the value you bring.

  📌 Example: "Let’s also factor in the level of service and long-term partnership we’re offering beyond the initial price."

By diffusing the initial anchor and strategically presenting your counter, you create room for a more balanced and productive negotiation.

Final Thought

Negotiation is as much about psychology as it is about numbers. The ability to set and defend a strong anchor gives you a significant advantage, making it easier to influence outcomes and maximize value. Whether you're negotiating a salary, a deal, or a business contract, anchoring—when done right—ensures you stay in control of the discussion.

Here are the key takeaways to remember:

✅ Preparation is Non-Negotiable

✅ Be the First to Anchor

✅ Justify Your Anchor

✅ Frame Your Anchor Effectively

✅ Use Strategic Extremes When Needed

✅ Control the Narrative Before Anchoring

The best negotiators don’t just react to anchors—they set them. And the key to setting a strong anchor starts with preparation. Research, plan, and frame your anchor effectively, and you’ll have a powerful edge in any negotiation.

Stay Connected for more Insights